Name: Goodfella's Pizza
Price range: $$

Goodfella's Pizza Information

Stepping into Goodfella's Pizza at 6 W Union St in Athens feels like slipping into a cozy neighborhood joint where the aroma of fresh-baked dough hits you before anything else. The moment you walk in, the casual, no-frills atmosphere immediately puts you at ease-brightly lit but warm, with simple tables that invite both a quick bite and a lingering meal with friends. The menu strikes a perfect balance between classic pizza offerings and inventive twists, so whether you’re craving a traditional pepperoni or something more adventurous like their loaded veggie or BBQ chicken pies, there’s a satisfying option for every palate. Crusts here are golden and just the right level of crispiness, with a chewy interior that makes every slice feel indulgent without being heavy. The cheese stretches generously, and the toppings are fresh and thoughtfully balanced, showing attention to detail that makes each bite memorable. Beyond pizza, the menu includes hearty sandwiches, fresh salads, and shareable appetizers, which makes it easy to grab a full meal or just snack while catching up with friends. The staff is friendly and attentive without being overbearing, creating a welcoming vibe that locals often praise in reviews. Whether dining in or taking your order to go, the service is consistent, and the kitchen keeps up even during peak hours without sacrificing quality. The location itself adds to the experience-right in the heart of Athens, it’s convenient for both students and long-time residents looking for a reliable spot to satisfy pizza cravings. Regulars often note that the combination of generous portions, reasonable prices, and a menu that doesn’t compromise on flavor keeps them coming back. It’s the kind of place where you can experiment with different pies or stick with your tried-and-true favorite and still walk away feeling genuinely satisfied. For anyone exploring the local food scene, Goodfella's Pizza manages to deliver that comforting, familiar taste while maintaining a level of craftsmanship that sets it apart from typical takeout spots.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

We love going to Goodfellas on Court Street. Their pizza is freshly baked with a soft, delicious crust, and the cheese pizza is especially amazing. It always satisfies our cravings. We go at least once a month — it’s our little tradition now. The staff is always kind and fun, which makes it even better!

Nostalgia attack everytime I get pizza here. I was a student at OU and ate here countless times. The pizza is unique and absolutely delicious. I can't think of anywhere I'd rather get pizza from in Athens. Eat here. Every chance you get you should eat here. Edit: Ate lunch and dinner here the other day. Nothing has changed. Still the best pizza in Athens.

The best pizza ever its worth driving from another town for. . My Dog Loves It too. . Seen some of the reviews that says the crust is soft and gave a bad review its thick crust its supposed to be soft. Best pizza ever.

Nice smell to the place. pizza is very good. the dough isn't like what you get at a chain pizza it gives it a nice textu and taste. and the workers are friendly

Went to Athens with the family for a quick little trip for dinner and to surprise the youngins! We ordered a 1/2 sheet pepperoni and a slice of cheese pizza plus 3 bottles of water, a Dr Pepper and A Lemon Lime Gatorade! The cook/waitress was extremelynice and helpful! They offer a special of 2 slices or pepperoni or cheese pizza and drink for $7! Their pizza is a large rectangle and I cant wait to devour it! I'mon a diet and Tomato restricted due to stomach health but Im with my familyand this is their choice option .. I LOVE LOVE LOVE Pizza and this did not disappoint! It's thick like Detroit Pizza! Very good and highly recommend if you are in the Athens area!! Literally right near Ohio University in Walking distance... Let me know your experience!

Incredible tasting Detroit style pizza, I love the soft and doughy crust, and our order was fresh and ready when we got there!

The pizza is GREAT it's a deep dish but the sizes they have are half sheet or full sheet or you can buy by individual slice idk if buying the half sheet or full comes half cheese and half pepperoni even though I said for entire pizza I got the half sheet which is 8 slices But its really really EXPENSIVE but for trying it for my first time I wasn't disappointed

Good pizza, great price! The employees here have a great sense of humor, treat them kindly and they will return the favor and then some. There's nothing better than getting a fresh slice of pepperoni pizza with the garlic butter on the crust. It makes for a cheap meal thats filling and tasty! They do specialize in late night drunk food, but the quality is great and I would eat here mid-day sober.

Goodfella's Pizza